Hello Bris Dave,
Sorry it took a bit to get back with you on this discussion. I was typing a reply back last night and the phone rang so I lost my thought.
The debate between the NF 16-inch and Coiltek 14-inch round mono's is a good discussion. I would agree the 16-inch round would get a bit more depth, but it's not enough to say the coil is "better." I think we would have to compare like sizes before that determination could be justified. I personally own both coil, but have been far more successful with the Coiltek 14-inch round. I have probably found over 500 nuggets and all my biggest gold with this coil. Naturally when someone has been very successful with something they tend to go back to it. My 14-inch Coiltek is wore completely out, so I'm considering a new one. For the time being the Wallaby DD Pro and Mono have done a very good job.
I think the 14 & 16-inch round are great choices.
I agree with you, that some coils work much better over certain ground conditions than others. I found the Wallaby DD Pro to be the best coil (here in Arizona) for out right prospecting. It can find smaller gold than the conventional Minelab, Coiltek and NF DD searchcoils due to the stronger electro-magnetic field (more power applied to the searchcoil).
As far as replacing wore out coils, I understand the logic behind it. I used to use the Coiltek coils (especially the 14-inch round) without a coil cover. I think you get a bit more added sensitivity, but some seem to disagree. Regardless, this is what I did in the past and would eventually wear the bottoms completely off the coils. However, usually I would have a handful of nuggets to justify destroying the searchcoil. I'm sure the same logic is applied to the guys wearing out the fiberglass searchcoils.
I would agree the NF 14-inch would overall beat both of the coils you mentioned. Reason being, the Coiltek 10x5 Joey is much smaller vs. the 14-inch elliptical. You should get a bit more depth and more coverage with such a coil. As for the Minelab 11-inch round (mono), I'm not convinced the NF14-inch elliptical would find them smaller, as I have found them almost under a grain with the 11-inch, and under a grain (0.8 grains) with the Minelab 8-inch round mono at or near the surface with the GP series detectors. When it comes to depth, I'm still real skeptical about the NF getting more depth. Mathmatically, they should have about the same depth capabilities.
Dave, you are right, is some places all your reports might be dead on, but others spots it might be just the opposite. This includes my findings also. I have never detected Australia, so my findings here in the US could be much different on those coil conditions.
Regardless, this thread has been very interesting and would love to hear more about your reports. It never hurts to have a few coils from each manufacture to increase your chances overall in the various goldfields.
P.S. Would love for you to join my forums and contribute any information. Being a Minelab and Coiltek dealers, I still enjoy to hear about other products on the market. There never is just one best combination!
Hope to hear back from you,
Rob Allison
Rob's Detector Sales
www.nuggethunting.com