Hi Pax,
I cant speak to the Vaq, and Im a rookie at MDing in general, but here is what I see as potential negatives with the Outlaw so far-
-poorly written instruction manual. I think at one point in there, it referred to the Tejon. So I think someone did a bad cut and paste job from other manuals instead of taking the time to wirte a well conceived set of instructions for this specific detector. For instance, the Retune feature is not well described. The interaction (or lack thereof) between threshold/all-metal/Disc/retune is not covered but there have certainly been questions about them.
-The depth it gets in real-world situations (not air test, not freshly burried coins in a garden) is easliy 8 inches on quarter-sized objects. I havent found any coins more than about 6 inches, but bottle caps, nails, and pull tabs have routinely rung out at 8-9 inches with the 8 inch donut coil. Much much deeper (16 inches +) on big iron. I dont know if thats a negative or not--just depends on how deep you want to go.
-It is a pleasant sounding machine once in opertation mode, but the battery check at power-up sucks.
-Ive had stability problems at weird times, but I dont know enough about detectors to say whether or not ANY detector would have issues under the same situations. It could also be user-error...
-The Retune button has a steep (for me) learning curve, but a few gentlemen on this forum have helped with this and I think once mastered, it can be a great asset for those hunting with All-metal mode.
I dont know if those are universal "negatives"for the Outlaw or just what Ive struggled with because of my lack of experience. I hope it helps though.