I read a great quote here on Findmall, I think it was in a post by Elton or Monte. Anyway, it goes something like "You have to learn to fit your detector, because it won't learn how to fit itself to you."
If you read the manuals, they state right off that ID is a guide. If you're expecting 100% correct ID, it's going to elude you. It's not just sounding off on a whim with lottery number ID, there's a reason behind every beep or boop. All it takes is a little testing and taking the time to understand what's going on.
If somebody doesn't care for the "bells and whistles," that's fine, but it's counterproductive to make litlle of it. There's other models and brands that treat the signals differently, have other bells or dispense with them entirely. There's really no need for derogatory posts right, Mark? I may not use all the features, and you'll find most of them can be switched off if not wanted. Myself, I wouldn't enjoy the hunt as much without having the option of at least clicking over to check a signal in several different modes before digging. I didn't learn some of them overnight, but it's neat that I can grow into a machine learn more from it anytime I choose to make the effort.
I find BB-sized native iron in my yard I can collect with a magnet, but unseen otherwise and hard to even pinpoint. But the detector finds 'em no problem and it is very confusing till you find the source of a nuisance signal like that.
I've learned a lot just by experimenting with the iffy ID problem. Try slowing sweep speed to a crawl after hitting these types of signals. Now you might find two different items instead of just one "merged" ID. Or try ultra-short sweeps just over the signal itself. Don't sweep the coil so both outside edges go beyond the "center" of the signal. Just "putt" with the coil, keeping the center coil or rib of a DD coil over the target. For bottlecaps and .22 shells and some other items, try bobbing the coil up and down over it. You may find ID shifted down to iron, while "good" targets keep their high tones.
These are all things you can try with tossed down targets in your own yard or anywhere.
I made some coil sensitivity "graphs" and posted that in another thread. I discovered certain "bad ID" areas or patterns and unusual detection areas that can help explain some kinds of poor ID and why objects can be detected in places other than "dead-center" beneath the coil.
You can of course avoid all ID problems and most of the odd coil patterns by hunting in all-metal and digging everything. But just because some people think that's the only way to do it doesn't mean that's the way I choose. I much prefer ID with a little guesswork to all-metal and all-guess.
-Ed