Hi Erik.
First thing...the headphones aren't irrelevant because of the very reason you stated...the signal he heard would not be the same as I hear...because the sound I hear is going through my headphones....not split off before it gets there like it would be for Aaron.
The impact of the factors is a very big issue...at least for me...which is why I haven't made a recording.
Many times on a hunt I have called people over to hear the sound. I always hold my hadphones out and let everyone listen.
In each and every case...they state it isn't the sound they are hearing when they run their machine over the target.
I'm not sure why that is...but it just is.
There is no "magic" signal to listen for...and a variability change of just one number different drasticly changes the tone one hears...so all the factors I mentioned do come into play.
There are tons...and I mean tons of videos on youtube that have people doing exactly what is being requested. If you notice they ALL sound like a deep coin....but they are also ALL different in some way. Each signal recorded is unique in some way from each and every other one...at least to me.
True they all sound like deep coins...but to me...I hear subtle differences in many of them.
Anyway my point is that I do not have a "magic" sound...just the deepie sound that I have trained my ears to listen for.
I just clicked on the video that was posted in this thread by jeffmrgan...and it is definately a nice sweet deepie sound...and is very similar to what I listen for.
Is it exactly what I hear each time....no...but it is a textbook example of a "deepie"...which is the point I'm trying to make.
Anyway...not looking to argue...and I know you weren't either. We were just both trying to make a point.
There are a ton of different, sweet deepie sounds...and tons of vids to show them. It's up to each of us to train our ears to listen for ANY of them....because mine isn't "magic".
My point...the sound posted in the vid in this thread is not exactly the sound I hear is...but it's VERY similar. Would I dig it ...YEP..because it's one of many sweet sounds I listen for when hunting.
Take care Erik...and thanks for responding to the post. It's what keeps the forum going...and it helps people learn.