I've finally broken down and watched several episodes of this show.
My first observation is that this is not a good thing for the hobby, but it is about what you would expect from a non-reality "reality" show.
With hundreds of TV channels looking for programming, the hobby was fortunate to avoid the reality vultures for as long as it did.
Very few outside the hobby would watch a program showing a true representation of metal detecting. This show is produced for the millions of people who don't metal detect but have daydreamed of finding buried treasure, it is not made for those of us who truly do metal detect.
The annoying camera angles bother me, especially the one they continually use from the ground that shows the two guys twisting unnaturally with the detector.
And the stupid competition bets they have every show where the buffoon who loses the best find competition gets something foolish done to him as punishment.
And the idiotic terms they use for their finds and the way they act like morons jumping in trees, falling on their face, etc. when they make a good find.
But I understand why they do all of the above. If you're going to have a show about metal detecting you have to spice it up. Because metal detecting ain't a spectator sport. It's basically a darn boring thing to watch someone do.
What REALLY bothers me is that the show can't be bothered to take a few precious seconds to show proper retrieval techniques so the many novices who see this show and decide they are going to go out and find their great fortune don't go to their local historic park and tear it up.
Worst of all, the inflated and completely erroneous value of the finds. A 1928-D penny with a value of $25? In what world is a 1928-D penny out of the ground ever worth more than a few cents at best? The inflated value of the finds has the negative effect of making a lot of the kiddies who watch these kind of shows want to take up metal detecting and find all that instant treasure. Virtually all of those who do will drop out of detecting when they realize what detecting is really about. But they'll leave their property and who knows what other damage behind to the detriment of those of us who love this hobby.
But it doesn't matter what I think. It doesn't matter what you think. King Dufus, the Dorkmaster, and the producers of this show are no doubt laughing all the way to the bank.