Hi Rob,
What is better, in your opinion, about the Minelab type connectors? In view of what you say, I guess the larger pins are one plus point. The plugs and sockets that Minelab use, are of good quality, with gold plating on the pins/receptacles. There are similar types available here, but the quality is inferior and no gold plating.
Plugs and sockets are a critical component in a PI metal detector, any poor connection will generate noise and instability. It has to carry both the pulse current from the transmitter and conduct the microvolt signals coming back from an object. They must also be mechanically durable, and survive dust, grit and moisture. Metal bodied connectors also give a good degree of electrical shielding to the "live" pins, to minimise noise. The body has, of course, to be grounded to do this.
Regarding the Amphenol connectors, I have used these since around 1990, and have experienced very few problems. The most likely fault is that the coil connector is never unscrewed from the one on the box. If the detector is a beach machine, this can result in seized threads, from salt corrosion. I alway recommend unscrewing the coil connector reasonably frequently, brushing the threads off with an old toothbrush, and giving a LIGHT smear of WD40.
There is no problem with changing to a ML style connector, except that the panel hole is smaller and you will need to make a bush to take up the slack.
Eric.