D&P-OR (Del) and after1, thanx for the inputs.
After1, I think your experience (of thinking that IH "sounded different") can be explained in the following way: Each thing we find "sounds different". When you go to dig ANY target, you're thinking (when you stop to stoop down and dig) "this one sounds different". But when it turns out to be junk, you promptly forget your premonitions. However, when one turns out to be a goodie (an IH, or a gold item, etc...), then ONLY THEN do you remember your premonitions and think "aha! I knew it!". That's not to say the item didn't "sound different". Of course it did. All items (with the slightest depth or tilt difference or shape or size or composition) will ALL "sound different" from each other.
It's the trick of selective memory bias. Example: Have you ever woken up to your radio alarm clock TO THE VERY SONG that you were JUST dreaming about. You will think "aha! I'm psychic". But the truth is, we all dream 100's of dreams per night, none of which come true. So we forget them 10 seconds after waking up. However, if one of them coincidentally comes true , then only THEN do you remember and think "aha! I'm psychic !"
I detected with the fellow dealer fellow that this Larry is alluding to. And saw this subconscious trick at play between us (nothing malicious or purposeful, mind you): There was a certain athletic field known amongst md'rs in this area to still pork out some deep hiding old silver and wheaties. Years ago, we had agreed to meet up there to try out a new machine on the market. The idea was, that we would flag signals to compare, then see how this new machine stacked up.
After about an hour, I had flagged a couple of wheaties, and we'd each compare. But I noticed that he, in turn, had not flagged anything that turned out to be an oldie so far . Which was fine, as he too was "just learning" this new machine, so that's not a slam to him or the machine. But I noticed the following psychological trick at play: Each time I'd find a deep high conductor whisper that I'd flag and call him over to hear, he would always concur: "Yup, I hear it" and then proceed to give glowing commentary as to how the machine was correctly calling it, etc.....
I began to suspect that he was subconsciously rating them high, because he knew that I had a reputation for getting deep oldies from this area. What I mean is, .... if someone is POINTING OUT AN EXACT SPOT and "calling" it, then it's only natural that .... when the next person swings OVER THAT EXACT SPOT, their mind will "ramp up" the "call". Especially if you know that the other person is fairly reliable on turf deepies, you'll tend to search your mind for ANY reason to "call it good". I began to wonder if he wasn't subconsciously being taken by this mind trick.
So I PURPOSEFULLY flagged one that I did NOT suspect would be anything except shallow low conductor trash. I called him over. And guess what ? He gave it glowing reviews of high potential. That confirmed that he was merely "ramping up" any signal I showed him. At the end of that hunt, I perhaps had 6 or so oldies (wheaties and a silver or whatever), and he had perhaps 1 + junk and clad. But that can simply be explained by the fact he was trying a brand new machine, so I'm not slamming him for that. Only trying to point out the trick of "memory bias".