Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

Mods on detector question????

A

Anonymous

Guest
I'm posting this here because of all the knowlegable people that hang out here. There are so many aftermarket tweaks that people do to detectors to get extra depth or sensitivity by replacing crystals or other components on the machines. How come the manufactures don't do this in the beginning? With all the technology available now and electrical geniuses working on new detectors why were these "improvements" missed? I must not be understanding something here. Does anyone have an answer?
Thanks, Ed
 
.....and what might work well in one type of ground may not work well elsewhere. In many cases, that "tweaking" amounts to nothing more than adding more in the way of user adjustability, such as manual ground balancing, adjustable threshold level, sensitivity or gain, discrimination vs. all-metal modes of operation, and so on. Simply stated, the more "operator control" you have over a machine, the more "tweaking" you can do without doing any kind of modifications to the internals. Some of the additions to certain machines amount to nothing more than adding such control where it was not provided on the machine "by design", at least not externally. Good examples are some of the manual ground balance functions added to machines with otherwise internal adjustment pots. Another is the simple exchange of certain components on some of the PI type machines that shorten the gate pulse delay to make them more sensitive to smaller items with less cross sectional mass (the Whites surfmaster PI was a good candidate). It's not always so much a matter of increasing the inherent capabilities of the machines, but increasing or simplifying the level of user control over the machine to do the "tweaking" externally according to the user's specific needs rather than having to depend on what the factory "thinks" is the "best average setting" for the greatest number of conditions.
But as far as actual component changes (other than adjustable controls), the operational stability of the machine is more often the primary concern. Any tradeoff in performance for stability can really be a two-edged sword. And when you're talking about an increase in target response especially, that usually includes ALL targets, including junk and ground signal.
Just a thought......
 
Also when a manufacturer builds a detector he has to make it so it works well over as broad a range of circumstances as possible. This requires compromises. When someone tweaks a machine for his area he may be making that same machine lose performance if it were used in other areas. An example of this is a post that was on one of the other Forums about them changing the crystal in the Minelab Sov to shift it's frequency. The reason that they do this is that in certain parts of England there is electrical noise that coincides with the operating frequency of the Sov making it essentially unusable so they came of with the soultion of changing the crystal to slightly different frequency to eliminate the interference. There is no real way that Minelab could have forseen this problem since they are in Australia and thier machines like many other manufacturer's detectors are used all over the world. Manufacturers do thier best to make thier machines as versatile as possible but there is no way that they can see every eventuality that thier detectors may run up against. Sometimes it's just matter of making some small changes to make the detector perform a little better in your particular location.
HH
Beachcomber
 
Top