I have one with the smaller handle and it works great, It is my go to scoop when I dig in areas with lots of rocks and shells. For that work there is hardly any better. I do wish that Travis would come out with a bigger diameter bucket as due to the angled head of the scoop and its smaller size , you can sometimes take several scoops to find an item that you could have recovered in one with a larger bucket. Don't get me wrong the Nuttall scoop is one of the best you can buy for the money. I have just made this realization after using it for a couple of years and having had the opportunity to use other designs as well. If Travis does design a wider ,bigger bucket, I will be the first to buy one. I have three scoops now. The Nuttall Diamond head (with the short fiberglass handle), an RTG Aluminum sand scoop, and an all Stainless RTG Hercules. Out of all of them I have tried to use the Aluminum the most with weight as my biggest consideration (it also has a bigger bucket) but, it doesn't have a metal lip and without one it will fray over time. I do think my next purchase maybe a large aluminum scoop with a metal lip. The Hercules is an awesome water scoop. It makes a two and a half scooper a one scoop, and it has the weight to hold you in place while your up to your neck digging. The only problem is carrying it around. Damn thing will break your clavicle...lol