You, know John, your argument goes around in circles to what I and other's post!
My argument is the same and hasn't varied - itis the witness of Scripture. Your argument hasn't varied - it is the witness of your own opinion, without Scripture.
Unless the Spirit of God draws the lost souls of sinners, they will not be saved
You agree then, that
only God can draw the unregenerate out of the world and save them. But, unfortunately you side-step the truth that those that God draws are His elect only, chosen from before the foundations of the earth, and not simply 'anyone' that wants to be saved or anyone that has decided to choose God. I understand why you do this: you want to keep the salvation decision with man and not God. That is why Arminianism is so attractive to the prideful spirit and also why it is a doctrinal abomination.
but by our bowing and submitting to Jesus at the calling of the Holy Spirit that means any who are lost may come and partake of the goodness of God
You'd be wise to compare your salvation plan with God's - they are not the same, and one of you is wrong. God says we are not saved by the works we have done, not by our merit, not by our faith, or any 'thing' we do. You fail to grasp the simple truth that your "bowing and submitting" is as much a work as if you said "we are saved by giving money to the church" or "we are saved when we are baptized". Our submission to God is not possible apart from regeneration - the removal of the heart of stone, the giving of life to a spirit dead to good works - all done by the Holy Spirit and performed on only those Christ died, which again, is only those the Father gave Him to redeem. Our works don't save us - but after salvation our good works testify of our righteousness that is from Christ.
You can make endless claims that our bowing to Christ 'made' God save you - or, that God 'saw' your humility and decided you were worthy for salvation, whatever, it is the same faulty game. You have nothing in you to be admired by God - and further, you have nothing in you to seek God (no one seeks after God, no not one). So, where does that leave you? Obviously, it leaves the unregenerate helpless in their depraved and vile state without any means to save themselves. This is the problem with Arminians, they reject the true state of mankind and try to infuse some spark of 'goodness' into man so he can seek God, do a good work, 'accept' God, or some derivation of the thing. This is impossible with man (but not with God).
Though shown by Scripture over and over the folly of their salvation plan based on their good works - most will ignore God and run back to it for safety. The heart of fallen man will not allow God to be Sovereign King over them. They will allow God to be a King over things 'out there' somewhere, but will move heaven and earth to avoid God's Sovereignty over them, and endlessly torture Scripture so as to nullify all truth just to hold on to their belief in the sovereignty of man, they must remain the king-makers in salvation.
he saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit (Tit 3:5)
Arminians do not believe we are dead in sins - only sick, thus they teach we can reach out to God and accept God at any time. But God is not a liar - we
are DEAD, and reach out to no one for salvation. That is why the Bible says over and over that we are saved by GRACE by the MERCY of God and not of works - belief and reaching out is a work. If you could do something to initiate salvation then it wouldn't be by grace but by works, and therefore grace is nullified. Arminians will read the verse below and think, "Yes, we are saved by grace when we were yet dead in sins and made alive by Christ", and then add, "when we reached out to Him and let Him into our hearts".
Even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ, (by grace ye are saved) (Eph 2:5)
So many people can look right into the face of Scripture and read it a hundred times, but they cannot allow it to say what it means. If they did their entire works-plus-grace salvation plan would crumble. And why so much effort to distort and ignore Scripture? Because the heart of man is desperately wicked and loves the darkness - it is a proud heart that attempts to escape the meaning of God's word and pervert it for their own purposes. All this vanity and flailing about trying to keep their prideful hearts from being deflated. Either God saves by His grace those that He choose, and that while they are dead in their sins
OR God chooses those who already chose Him (absurd and illogical) and with their spark of goodness are saved by their itsy-bitsy work that earns them God's merit and by this act of volition they 'permit' God to save them. Take your pick - however, if you love God then you are inclined toward keeping His commandments and if you don't you won't - so chose carefully. Your choice says a great deal about you.
You think no one has to do anything for themselves at all to be saved and the way I understand you, that God does it all!
Wouldn't it be wonderful if you actually understood that this is exactly what salvation is: God does it all!!!! But, sadly you are only stating the premise so you can deny it. You are confused in thinking that when God saves (by His grace) those who are the recipients of God's work (no ours) we are still the same creature. In truth, we are no longer the same - that is why regeneration is so important. When the Holy Spirit regenerates those that Christ was the propitiation for (His elect), they become
a new creation. It is out of this new creation and this new living spirit that the ability to believe is born. Because of God's work we will begin to seek Him out receive truth when God reveals it. All these good works manifest themselves following salvation, as God foreordained they would, but not prior to regeneration. That means, we do not have the spiritual ability prior to salvation - we do not seek, or believe, or have faith in God (in a false god - yes), or understand, or want to do the will of God. These all follow the new birth (a birth that is from above - that is - God).
For it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of His good pleasure. (Php 2:13)
It is God's good pleasure to save some of mankind. It was God's good pleasure to choose a people for Himself. When Christ died for the Father's choice - He led captivity (to Satan) captive (to Christ) and delivered many by His blood. He did not save the 'whole world', else the whole world would be saved. He saved from God's eternal wrath those sheep given to Him by the Father and was glorifed by the Father for His obedience. Those that are saved were, in essence, with Christ on the cross - the sins of each elected person was taken with Christ, so we are free from the charge of the Law against us, Christ having fulfilled the penalty of the Law (which is eternal death).
But that is not the end of the matter. God did not just raise Christ from the dead and leave the elect in their fallen state until the day they die (though He could have). By God's grace, He applied to His elect the first installment of salvation -- a new living spirit. The second installment will be a new resurrected body (at the end of this earth we who believe shall be changed). In neither case, not at our first natural birth, or at our spiritual birth, nor at when we receive our new bodies did our will, desire, wants, decision, works, efforts, plans, etc. enter into the equation. We are the object of God's love - even when we didn't love God. Not a sappy love - but a love that is expressed in action.
Ye have not chosen me, but I have chosen you, and ordained you, that ye should go and bring forth fruit, and that your fruit should remain: that whatsoever ye shall ask of the Father in my name, he may give it you. (Joh 15:16)
Being chosen by God is not something we do by waving our hands about to get God's attention, despite the claims of Arminians. We are chosen by God and ordained to good works - we bring forth fruit while we are spiritually alive, not when we are spiritually dead. In Adam the whole human race fell into spiritual darkness but in Christ all those to be redeemed out of that mass of humanity are made alive.
For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive. (1Co 15:22)
The wicked are appointed to wrath - but those that believe were appointed to obtain salvation. The Arminian would say "because they believed" were they appointed. But God says He chose His own before the world began, before we had done anything either good nor bad, so that no man can boast. Yet the Arminian can and does boast, "if I had not reached out and accepted the free gift and condescended to permit Jesus into my life, I could not have been saved". What is this? The creature permits God to do His will? What arrogance!! What lies!!
For God hath not appointed us to wrath, but to obtain salvation by our Lord Jesus Christ (1Th 5:9)
What then? Israel hath not obtained that which he seeketh for; but the election hath obtained it, and the rest were blinded (Rom 11:7)
We are appointed to salvation and we obtained it! Not by works but by grace, not out of ourselves it is a gift of God. Therefore, those that are "the election", which means "the chosen", are saved (all will be saved), and the rest remain blind in their spiritual darkness. How do we obtain salvation? - "... by our Lord Jesus Christ", that's how. He just didn't make salvation '
possible', as the Arminians claim - He made it absolutely sure to those He was given to die for. This is the beauty of God's salvation - it is 'obtained' and it is 'ordained', therefore God can say He will loose none of His own.
And this is the Father's will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day. (Joh 6:39)
So, again and again, the same God-breathed message: We are saved not by works but according to His Divine Will, and not to all mankind is salvation given but to all those given to the Son to die for and this "before the world began". So where is the boasting? There is no room for claiming we did this or that and that made God do this or that, that is an oft repeated lie in the church today - but it doesn't get truer through repetition.
Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began (2Ti 1:9)
Can God say it any plainer? We have faith and believe and do good works because before the world was created God the Father selected a people for Himself. This same group, called His elect, are the object of His love. Jesus was sent into the world for this purpose, to take their sins with Him on the cross - and make the payment - not for the whole world, but to the election it was given. These are the sheep that Christ came to seek and save. And lo and behold, God the Holy Spirit regenerates each one of God's elect (not because they sought Him) - and lo and behold, they LIVE! And
AFTER they are born from above by God - they possess the power to believe to see truth and hate lies, an outward manifestation of God's inner-work.
If we didn't answer when called and then study the Word, diligently, to grow in faith and wisdom and serve Him by worshiping Him in Spirit and in Truth, we could just say we are saved and sit in the pews and on our own Laruels and not do anything....
Your underlying presumption is concerning God's call to salvation anyone at all can decide to answer it and be saved - and that is simply
not the case, as we have seen. Many are called, they hear and do not believe, but few are chosen. Only the elect hear - and that because they are given 'ears to hear'.
For many are called, but few are chosen. (Mat 22:14)
You describe the church today very well: "
we could just say we are saved and sit in the pews and on our own Laruels and not do anything". We could say with Kevin Costner: "If we make a man-centered salvation program, then they will come". If we create a false salvation program, and many will join-up and 'accept Jesus' according to the rules of the salvation program. You'd have churches filled with members who are 'saved' in accordance to that program. And you do today. It would be a church filled with people who are professing Christians but who have zero interest in obeying the word of God and humbling themselves to God's commands. Sure, they claim humility and obedience, but when pushed they run from it. Why? Because a false gospel yields a false faith in a false salvation that cannot save. Sure, they say Lord, Lord and go forth to spread their false gospel thinking they are doing God's will. But in the end, the revealing will show who is the sheep (they hear God's voice and obey) and who are the goats (and the wolves in sheep's clothing).
Many will say to Me in that day, Lord! Lord! Did we not prophesy in Your name, and through Your name throw out demons, and through Your name do many wonderful works? And then I will say to them I never knew you! Depart from Me, those working lawlessness! (Mat 7:22-23)
What does it mean that God "never knew" them? Does it mean God is unaware of the people He created? No. Rather, it means that they were not 'known' by God intimately as those who are ordained to life - they weren't foreknown by God and called by name for salvation. The unregenerate hate God but they are quite willing and happy to love an idol. They joined up with a false salvation without reservation and are willing to worship a God that they create for themselves - a God that pleased them and is obedient to their thinking. Is there anything new under the sun?
How do you know if you are predestined for salvation or not? You don't, at least not in your initial rebellious state - for salvation is God's business. However,
if you are
now the Workmanship of Jesus Christ then you
will observe in yourself a transformed life. You will read the Bible and learn from God - and you will obey what you learn. You will hate sin more and more, and you will grow in sanctification (holiness) - being less and less like the world and more and more Christ-like. We are called to judge ourselves to make sure we are in the faith. Certainly, if we believe hideous doctrines that are antithetical to God's word and close our eyes and stop our ears to our error - then we have our witness. It is one thing to find error and be teachable and correctable - that is the way of sanctification as ordained by God, growing more Christ-like by being conformed to His image. But it is another thing to trample underfoot the word of God and claim ourselves to be His - these are mutually exclusive things. That is why God warns that many will be cast out - the Lawless Ones - for they are a law unto themselves - they rejected the Word of God and thereby show they do not want God to rule over them. It is very simple - if you love God you will obey Him and if you don't you will seek out many diversion and devices.
THAT MEANS WE DO SOMETHING OURSELVES and not just think we are all okay and the ones God has predestined to be saved are saved and the rest who aren't predestinated just go into the Lake of Fire and have nothing to do with their salvation at all!
The ones predestined to salvation are the ones called by God with an effectual call (not just the general call that goes to all the world). Before Jesus could call Lazarus out of the tomb He had to do something to him first - of course, give him life. For the calling of God to bring anyone to Christ they have to be alive first. To say, "Lazarus come forth" while he is but a corpse would be futile. Obviously, before anyone can "
do something ourselves" we first are made alive in order to do it - not physically but spiritually, and not by our works but by the works of God. Afterwards, we then go forth to do the good works God ordained us to walk in, but not without or apart from the re-birth. But, Arminianism says Lazarus is not completely dead - he has a spark of life to reach out to God and rise and come to Him. God says that is a lie. You be the judge and decide for yourself which is true.
For by grace you are saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God, not of works, lest anyone should boast. For we are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus to good works, which God has before ordained that we should walk in them. (Eph 2:8-10)
Arminianism makes the cart pull the horse - it insists man drive the salvation vehicle and puts God in the cart to go along for the ride. Like some divine genie - when man is sufficiently ready (a Biblical impossibility) he decides to accept Christ into his heart - and by this magic incantation, poof, they have made God save them. It is pleasing to man because it is all of man, man, and man. Rather, God says salvation is
not of works but the elect are saved by grace - we are HIS Workmanship. But the Arminian will have none of it. God says we are created (anew) in Jesus Christ for a purpose. That purpose is to do His good works - like our belief, growing in faith, producing the continuous fruit of regeneration, and spreading the gospel (the true gospel that comes from God mind you, not a gospel out of our own heads). And God says further that our good works were
ordained beforehand by God - we are only doing them by His power and grace. Wow! The Root and Vine supports the branches giving the branches life - Christ is the Root and Vine and the believers are the branches while the false gospels have the branches in-grafting the Root.
No, it is God Who calls and then we must accept the calling of His Holy Spirit and be repentant of all our sins by bowing and submitting our all to Jesus
I notice you never, like most Arminians, use Scripture to support your claims. But you say "
we must accept the calling" but God says something entirely different.God say HE does the effectual calling that saves - and it is not as man would have done it. That is, God calls out of the world those who are despised by the world - God choses the foolish things (in men's eyes) in order to confound the wise (in their own eyes). Who did the calling out of the world so that some are saved? God did! Who did the choosing - man or God? God did! Where does it say we have to decide for Christ and our will is supreme in the matter? No where - because that is not how we are saved.
For you see your calling, brothers, that not many wise men according to the flesh are called, not many mighty, not many noble. But God has chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise; and God has chosen the weak things of the world to confound the things which are mighty (1Co 1:26-27)
Oh, if the Arminian could allow the truth from God's own mind to penetrate their stubborn prideful refusal to let go of their need to drive the cart - they would know the beauty of God's salvation. But how many will? Again, only those God has called and ordained to eternal life will believe.
For so the Lord has commanded us, saying, "I have set You to be a light of the nations, for salvation to the end of the earth." And hearing, the nations rejoiced and glorified the Word of the Lord. And as many as were ordained to eternal life believed. (Act 13:47-48 )
I just don't think a Loving God, Who gave His own life in our place, would be so unloving to condemn some forever without a choice to be saved or to appoint (predestinate) others to be with Him forever in Paradise!
For My thoughts are not your thoughts, nor your ways My ways, says Jehovah. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are My ways higher than your ways, and My thoughts than your thoughts. (Isa 55:8-9)
Thankfully, you do not get to design your own salvation program - even if you do. The mind of man apart from God is carnal and does not understand the things of God. He takes the things of God and pulls them down to his level - making the salvation of God into a salvation men can approve. Men think that God is unfair if He doesn't provide salvation to everyone. Yet, what is fair would be for all of mankind to be sent directly to hell - that God saves any is a testament to His Mercy. Men think it unfair if salvation is all of God and none of man. Yet, knowing the depravity of man, should God heed the Arminian and wait for him to decide for Christ? Well, under that program there would be none saved!, for not one of us can or wants to be saved in our rebellious state. So, God does not heed the Arminian - for they are fools and God is wise.
And yes, God does condemn forever some without a choice to be saved. Do you think the Hittite empire heard the gospel? How many nations rose and fell (by the dictates of God) without ever hearing the gospel? Do you think prior to the Flood that anyone living then would have wanted salvation at some point but were killed before they had the chance? No Way! The heathen are in rebellion and work evil continuously - there is no fear of God before their eyes. When God destroyed Sodom, were there babies and children destroyed? - yes absolutely. How could a loving God blot people out without giving them the gospel? Because God knows, as I know, as many who read there Bible know - that they are not
EVER going to believe and be saved. Why? For the reason I have given by the testimony of many Scriptures (which you won't receive): They are not foreknown by God and therefore are not appointed to believe!!
God can wipe out everyone on earth 7,000 years ago because just like today - none of them will turn to Him and repent. He doesn't need to bring the gospel to them and offer them anything -- their wills are in bondage to Satan and they hate God -that is the reality of their fallen state. Is there anything different today? Do not many sit in churches and speak of the love of God - but when presented with the mind of God - are they not repulsed and revile God for doing things His way and not theirs. Can the leopard change its spots? Yes, the religious can feign love for God - but they will not receive the truth so that they should be saved (not apart from God and not unless they are His elect). While Sodom and Gomorrah or the Flood were judgments by God on wicked men - the real judgement is yet to be. On that day God will pour His eternal wrath on the ungodly - that is why we persuade men to believe - that is why I write to you, that if God has ordained it, you might believe and be saved from the wrath to come.
If you don't like what is posted on here than go to a Forum which believes like you do, where all can agree! You are welcome on here but don't push your beliefs on the rest of us
You only know my beliefs because I gave the testimony of Scripture. It is the Scripture that speaks not me. But, even if I do speak it is in the hope that some will hear and believe the words of Life, for it is God's truth not mine. My beliefs and your beliefs and everyone's beliefs everywhere are vain and meaningless -
unless they are in accordance with and in harmony with all Scripture. The Scriptures cannot lie - if the many verses I provided teach a truth you do not agree with, then your fight is with God, for the Bible is the mind of God, not of men.
You see, in usual Christian circles it is considered ill-mannered to assert anything to be absolute and true under all conditions. The professing Christian embraces relativism as much as the reprobate - they say, there is your truth and my truth - but don't push your truth on anyone else, because your authority is not greater than any other - we all must have our own private interpretations, all is equally true. Thus, the professing Christian can declare they are at peace, when in fact, God is at war with them. The foolish person makes peace through compromise and by feigning ignorance, but God is not mocked.
For when they shall say, Peace and safety! Then sudden destruction comes on them, as travail upon a woman with child. And they shall not escape. (1Th 5:3)
The fact is, many many professing Christians are thinking they are good - they attend a benign church, where they aren't bothered or offended by biblical truth because there is none. They can play their role and hold to whatever teachings they find worthy - those that build their self-esteem. They can quibble about meaningless things but do not ever upset their world speaking the things of God - they are quite content - they just want to be left alone with their own personal revelations.
How can you believe, you who receive honor from one another and do not seek the honor that comes from God only? (Joh 5:44)
Anyone can smile and be pleasant if we speak of God 'up-there' somewhere and how much He loves everyone - no threat. Everyone can accept a salvation by works - nothing to be offended at (pride is intact). Everyone can be happy if we preach Christ did everything for us and now we must make our decision for Him - it is understood by all that we are still the ringleader of our salvation, so no problems there. We can be at peace if we believe whatever we like and teach whatever we want, for it is understood that we are the final arbiter of truth, so all is well. But, don't insist there is absolute truth, for that implies we are wrong, and more than wrong, that our refusal to believe is rebellion against God. Like the Pharisees of old, they could not gainsay against the beauty and authority of the word of God, they knew Jesus was right, but they wouldn't believe it. Though their private interpretations were broken to pieces by the authority of Scripture, they clung to them anyway. So they sought to rid themselves of the Ambassador of Truth, and killed the Chief Messenger. Is there anything new under the sun? We shouldn't be surprised that the same spirit that was in them is in the churched today.
And you shall be hated by all for My name's sake. (Luk 21:17)
Then indeed they departed from the presence of the Sanhedrin, rejoicing that they were counted worthy to be shamed for His name. (Act 5:41)
May God Bless each of us with the absolute truth of His Holy Word!
If you believe it is the Absolute Truth - then you have to ask yourself why you oppose it. That is the question for everyone. What will you do with the word of God? Ignore it, seek to wiggle out from under it, twist it to your liking, or, believe it as written and obey it. And if you do believe it, then you are by believing manifesting the good works of Christ in you! That is how we know that we are His - we receive the testimony of the word - for we who receive it are spiritually minded and not carnally minded, for the carnal mind cannot receive it.
But we have not received the spirit of the world, but the Spirit from God, so that we might know the things that are freely given to us by God. These things we also speak, not in words which man's wisdom teaches, but which the Holy Spirit teaches, comparing spiritual things with spiritual. But the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned. (1Co 2:12-14)
Yes, we CAN know truth - absolutely, for we received the Spirit from God that leads us into truth. If however, God's word is foolishness to you - then you have your witness. If you reject the wisdom of the world (such as Arminianism brings), then by that spiritual discernment you show yourself to be a child of God. The gospel cuts to life for those that believe - but it also cuts to death for those who reject it. So, don't be doubting but believe!
For to be carnally minded is death, but to be spiritually minded is life and peace (Rom 8:6)
For we are a sweet smell to God because of Christ in those being saved, and in those being lost; to the one, an odor of death unto death, and to the other, an odor of life unto life. And who is sufficient for these things? (2Co 2:15-16)
john