"...many more old bloated and bent rusty square nails deep, they are the ones that sound more like a coin... still have bits and pieces of brass around them though, and they also stayed in that 12 range.. I think its going to be quite confusing for most people in that type of trash."
Those are the ones, bent nails and pieces of square nails. They are the ones that make me dig... I usually know better but I always think, "if I don't dig it I will miss the find of the year". Switching to digital when I pinpoint almost always gives me an iron reading, so I am learning. The ET seems to ID iron better in ferrous and 2 tones but I don't want to hunt in that setting.
Thanks for clearing up the 'sizing' thing for me. I was confused about that.
I went out today to three sites. First one was in Kingston, the place I went yesterday... really bad soil. Lots and lots of iron and cinder. I didn't find anything but I felt better after I stuck my digger in the ground at a slight angle and buried, in three different places, a penny, a dime, and a nickel. The dime and the nickel promptly disappeared. I could not hit them with an SE, an E-Trac, a T2, or a Tejon... at about 6". So I left.
Went to another site and found a couple of zinc pennies. Then to an old lot in town... there I found several odd items, a 1919 cent and an 1890 V nickel... so I feel a little better about it.
I think I am going to like the ET. I don't think I will be able to justify keeping the SE... but I want to be sure... no regrets.
Thanks for all the help... you and everyone else.
J