It seems to me Bounty Hunter's reputation took a nose dive way back when they decided to start making their detectors almost entirely out of plastic. There seemed to be a philosophy change within the company after they moved from Arizona, and they seemed to have decided to quit competing with the big boys (White's, Tesoro, Fisher, etc. ) and focus entirely on the low end to mid range detector market.
When they were still in Arizona (late 70s - early 80s) Bounty Hunter detectors were almost all metal, high quality, and good dependable machines. I began detecting way back in the late 70s with Bounty Hunter detectors, my last and favorite being the Bounty Hunter "Red Baron". Great machine, and one of my all time favorites. Bounty Hunter seemed to be a cutting edge company ready to do battle with White's, Fisher, and Tesoro. Good machines with good reputations. Years later after their move we started seeing all these cheap plastic Bounty Hunter detectors and those really into metal detecting didn't like them at all. Again, I think the company did a complete change in it's target market, moving from the serious detectors to the more "hobby" detector market, and Bounty Hunter seemed to slip from the stage as a serious manufacturer of Professional type machines.
I worked in manufacturing for over 27 years and I know product reputations can be very quickly destroyed, ...... and take years and years to rebuild. I think this is what happened to Bounty Hunter. They had developed and built a good reputation, changed direction as a company and lost that reputation.
Still today, I think most guys really into detecting consider Bounty Hunter machines as just "Hobby" detectors for the occasional park detector hobbyist. Personally, I think they are fine for what they are.
Over the years, I have owned most of the high dollar machines made by Minelab, Fisher, Tesoro, Whites, and Garrett but have often hunted with brothers and friends using mid range Bounty Hunter detectors. Did they ever get frustrated due to "not finding as much as my high dollar machines", ......................... yes quite often in fact. Did they still have fun and find good stuff, ........... absolutely! There definitely was a difference in our abilities to find deep targets, id them, and not dig so much trash, ...... but that should be of no surprise due to the extra features their machines lacked. I really doubt Bounty Hunter expects it's $400 detector to compete with White's DFX, ......... no way. Those machines have different target markets, and to expect the Bounty Hunter to perform along side the DFX is nonsense. They are good machines for what they are and their intended market.