maybe it isn't critical as to where the needle points at rest. I'm going to guess that if you adjust the needle to point at a consistent spot with a particular target, that you can use that as a reference point for any future settings, or hunt site.
In other words, let's say you have a new, shiny, nickel pointing at 28 on the meter (the center of the Nickel wording on the meter face) when testing it on the ground with the coil held at 4 inches above the nickel, and with all other settings where you will use them during your hunting session at that location. It would seem that if you learn where other desirable targets read on the meter, they would be consistent if you set your meter to always point at 28 on a shiny, new, nickel once your other settings are made.
I'm thinking that maybe it isn't as critical where it points when the machine is off as much as when it's on, and where it points on a known target with all other settings made for that particular ground, on that particular day. Maybe the idea of the needle pointing to the same place when the machine is off isn't the real issue.
I know that in order to get the proper calibration on the SunRay meter for the Minelab Sovereign, I use to use a dime, and set the meter to just read 180 when passing the coil over the dime laying on the ground I was hunting. Perhaps a similar procedure should be used with the 5900/6000/XL Pro meter. I don't know.
Of course, on another note, it seems as though it makes sense for the needle to point to zero when the machine is on, and the other settings are on the (P)reset. Or perhaps it should point to zero when the machine is off. Or maybe it should point at zero with the machine on and held at waist level. Very confusing as to what is the ideal.
If you look closely at the meter, you will see that each target has a range associated with it. The Nickel wording on the meter face spans the numbers of 23 to 34. The Penny wording on the meter face spans the numbers of 46 to 66. The Dime wording on the meter face spans the numbers of 61 to 68. The Quarter wording on the meter face spans the numbers of 70 to 83. The Half wording on the meter face spans the numbers of 80 to 88. The Dollar wording on the meter face spans the numbers of 88 to 100.
According to the manual, these variances in indication are due to alloy inconsistencies in the various coinage over the years. That may be the case, however the wording on the meter face is of a consistent size and typeface. It seems too coincidental that the alloys in the various coins would just happen to fit those ranges that the numbers/wording use. With that being said, it seems as though, and my experience shows, that a particular coin can fall anywhere within the numeric range under the target wording. The key is learning where that is on your meter, in the area you are hunting.
Another thing the manual brings up is that static electricity can affect the meter reading. Read what the manual says on page 34 (XL Pro). I think I will start using the anti-static clothes dryer sheets more frequently to avoid any static buildup.
Just some ramblings after thinking about your question more closely.
OldeTymer
TheTreasureLeague.com