capt. said:
The stock 11" DD IS a great coil. Just want to put that out there. In my soil, in the past ( because I just started detecting again after a 3 year hiatus) I believe the deepest I have dug with the NEL Tornado was a wheat penny at 7 + inches but it was an "iffy" signal... I could have easily walked away from it but chose to dig it. Most of my finds are 5 inches or less. For me, the benefit of the NEL coil is the separation and identification properties it brings to the game. Even in trashy areas that big coil was able to identify and allow me to pull good targets... it acts different or responds different to what is under it than the stock 11 inch. That's not to say it's magic or has super powers... I think that in my dirt in the areas I detect it allows the Gamma to be its very best. I remember once identifying a square modern pull tab some idiot threw on the ground that was now buried. I swapped to the stock 11 DD and only after swinging over the target much longer than I would under normal circumstances and from different angles did it finally give that little dip/break that I was looking for to let me know what it was. This will happen in 3 to 5 swings with the NEL coil. The numbers are a fairly solid (61/62?) but the give away is that dip/break.
Because I am rusty from years of inactivity I have no recent examples to share or numbers to give on the tabs... BUT... I assure you that (for me, in my area, disc 10, Sens 80 or higher, tones on 4) the NEL Tornado allows me to identify with a high degree of accuracy, nickels from pull tabs, and the type of tab... I just need to re learn what it is telling me. If I get rock solid numbers in any foil/nickel/pull tab area without the tell tales I dig it. I do think I remember that only twice did I dig a nickel that I was fairly certain was a tab but was not. Must have been a reason I checked... trash in the hole or something. I did post years ago about the NEL coil on my Gamma that may help because it was all fresh in my mind when I put it up. FWIW... the NEL Sharpshooter did a pretty good job for me the other day but it will take a while before it all sinks back in.
Having said all that... the best thing for recovering the most valuables is to dig it all. What works for me in my area may not work for you in yours. If it does, and you KNOW your machine, the NEL coil is a slight improvement over the 11 inch DD coil in my opinion but is not at all necessary for fun filled and successful outings.
capt.