I'd agree that say 2PM will hit deeper on targets that Auto won't hear or won't hit good, but there just seems something to be about auto that makes me feel it can reveal coins in really rough ground that even a low and stable manual sensitivity setting won't. I've dug a few good silvers with Auto at depth (close to 8", maybe some deeper), and some of those were standing on end. In really rough ground minerals or a ton of iron I think Auto will "track" the ground better and might reveal masked coins or ones being masked by the ground matrix better than a static manual setting. For sure it also helps when there is a lot of RF noise, though I'm finding the lowest manual setting even more stable when around RF noise in my garage testing targets. Come to think of it, I have yet to hear of anybody saying they've used Auto in All Metal With the All Metal Ground Tracking ON. That might be a real killer in the absolute worst of ground conditions that are changing VERY fast, such as in mixed dirt and iron at construction sites or old coal spill areas mixed with dirt, shale, and so on. Everybody knows of a site in their area that every guy who detects says "Can't be hunted. Ground conditions are just too bad." The few spots I've had like that in my area are fine for the GT using manual or Auto Discriminate, but I'm sure there are a few out there that still seem to hold out to any machine. I think I know of such a spot. Never hunted it but it sounds the worst yet with a good bit of potential in terms of old coins. For one it's got old pea stone gravel I know for sure, which in it's self isn't an obstacle but I've heard guys say it's a total no go for their machines. Hmmmm....I bet the GT in regular Disc/Auto mode will handle it, but maybe All Metal/Track/Auto will do even better.
The other thing about Auto is that I'd say it at least gets you near to optimum sensitivity settings. If you have manual set way too high (even if it sounds stable) or way too low for a certain spot then guess what...NULL CITY. Auto I bet will hit that coin in that case where as you wouldn't know it was there. Another problem is nearby RF noise that changes as you move closer/further away from it's source. Manual at one setting is good thirty feet away but thirty feet closer and it's starting to degrade target quality I think. I think that's why one of the coins (standing liberty quarter) I found at a spot I had pounded with my Explorers yet missed gave a perfect hit with the GT in Auto at like 7 1/4 to 7 3/4" (from memory). Besides the hot rocks, iron, stones, and minerals at this spot, there is also a nearby small FM transmitter. This spot gave me fits with any machine I've ever owned. The Explorer was the first to at least get coin signals that were say 70% there but never perfect and thus produced some old coins. However, the GT gave me PERFECT hits on coins at this spot and ran smooth while the Explorer never did despite changing settings. This was both with the 10" and 15x12 coils on the GT, where as the Explorer was using the stock 10" coil.