Fresh buried targets beyond 4" is a bad judgment for most if not all metal detector, no! I really can't explain why!
I know that it took over a year for a large US cent and an Indian Head Penny to get to where they were detectable with any success.
I've had the same thing happen with other fresh buried coins, sometimes they may hit for a few days and then disappear for months before a detector will hit on them again.
I've now got two Nickels buried at 7" that's been there near a year and unless I run MAX sensitivity and All Metal none of my detectors will hit on them, now the 8" Large Cents and the Indian Head penny a few feet away hit fine (same yard, same soil). Now in the same yard I have buried more shallow coins, less than 4" and I have never had a problem with them even the first day I buried them? they work just fine with any detector I've ever tried on them.
Now, I've mentioned this before on the forum and from the responses I get (or lack off) I get the idea that most just disregards me as being stupid, or just making this up. But my Brother Ron has had the same thing happen to him with a Fisher F75 and his Tejon. He buried a coin I believe it was 7", the F75 would not hit on it at all! the Tejon hit it pretty good. Then a short time later the Tejon quit hitting on it as well.
The last test gardens I did I went over the area with my 1266 clearing out any metal targets in the area before I planted the coins, same results! (I don't think this happens in sand, or on beaches).
Right now I have a 6" three coin garden that still don't work (near a year old now).
And I have the two 7" nickels that still don't work.
I also had a three coin 6" garden that NEVER worked and after a couple of years I just dug it up?
Whites Electronics claims that when you bury a metal object it disturbs the "Ground Matrix" and is not a good judge for a metal detector test. I don't know about the ground matrix, but what I do know is if I bury a coin here in West Virginia soil beyond 4" or so its not likely that a metal detector will fine it for a long time
Mark