I am new to the CTX and have only had the stock coil out 6 times and the 17" out twice, so I am no expert - but I find
the stock coil works great everywhere.
the good things about the 17" - it goes about 2 inches deeper, and covers twice the ground than the stock ( great for big low trash areas ).
the bad things about the 17" - it wears out my arm quicker, and it is harder to pinpoint with - the stock coil has a pinpoint hot spot right in the center so I just move the coil left and right, then for and aft, and your over the target in seconds. To me it seems like the 17" has three hot spots down the center line ( one at about each cross brace ). So to pinpoint I swing the coil left and right - but don't know if the upper, middle, or lower hot spot is sounding off - so to find out I draw a center line, then walk around 90 degrees, swing the coil left and right, draw a center line, and dig at the X.
this is in the wet or dry sand - seems to me the 17" would be hard to use under water in the surf.